TEACHING MATERIAL DEVELOPMENT: SPEAKING
·
INTRODUCTION
Speaking
is a productive skill. Theoritically,
according to O’Grady (1996) , it is a mental process. This means that it is a
psychological process by which a speaker puts a mental concept into some linguistic
form, such as word, phrases, and sentences used to convey a message to a
listener. So the speech production is the process by which the speakers turn
their mental concept into their spoken utterences to convey a message to their
listeners in the communicative interaction.
Much
recent work on optimal conditions for the teaching of speaking in second and
foreign language classrooms has been grounded in educational psycholinguistics
or in cognitive and social psychology. Theoretical constructs for language
pedagogy have been drawn extensively from empirical studies, underpinned by the
central notions of second language acquisition: communicative competence
(Canale and Swain 1980); comprehensible input (Krashen 1985), negotiated
interaction (Ellis 1990, Gass and Varonis 1994, Long 1983, Pica, et al.
1989), input processing (VanPatten and Cadierno 1993), developmental sequences
and routes of acquisition (Meisel, Clahsen and Pienemann 1981), and
communication strategies (Faerch and Kasper 1983). Such constructs are widely
taught in teacher preparation programs in second and foreign language teaching
and clearly have relevance to oral language instructional practice.
From
a communicative view of the language classroom, listening and speaking skills
are closely interwined. ESL. Curricula treat oral communication skills will
simply be labelled as “Listening/Speaking” course.
The
4 Language Skills
Add caption |
Skill #1: Listening
Skill #2: Speaking
Skill #3: Reading
Skill #4: Writing
Input is sometimes called "reception" and
output is sometimes called "production". Spoken is also known as
"oral".
Note that these four language skills
are sometimes called the "macro-skills". This is in contrast to the
"micro-skills", which are things like grammar, vocabulary,
pronunciation and spelling.
Why should we teach speaking
skills in the classroom?
Motivation
Many students equate being able to speak a language as knowing the language and therefore view learning the language as learning how to speak the language, or as Nunan (1991) wrote, "success is measured in terms of the ability to carry out a conversation in the (target) language." Therefore, if students do not learn how to speak or do not get any opportunity to speak in the language classroom they may soon get de-motivated and lose interest in learning. On the other hand, if the right activities are taught in the right way, speaking in class can be a lot of fun, raising general learner motivation and making the English language classroom a fun and dynamic place to be.
Many students equate being able to speak a language as knowing the language and therefore view learning the language as learning how to speak the language, or as Nunan (1991) wrote, "success is measured in terms of the ability to carry out a conversation in the (target) language." Therefore, if students do not learn how to speak or do not get any opportunity to speak in the language classroom they may soon get de-motivated and lose interest in learning. On the other hand, if the right activities are taught in the right way, speaking in class can be a lot of fun, raising general learner motivation and making the English language classroom a fun and dynamic place to be.
Speaking is fundamental to
human communication
Just
think of all the different conversations you have in one day and compare that with
how much written communication you do in one day. Which do you do more of? In
our daily lives most of us speak more than we write, yet many English teachers
still spend the majority of class time on reading and writing practice almost
ignoring speaking and listening skills.
Principles
for Teaching Speaking
• Focus on
fluency and accuracy (depending on lesson/activity objective)
• Use
intrinsically motivating techniques based on
student goals and interests
• Use authentic
language in meaningful contexts
• Provide
appropriate feedback and correction
• Optimize the
natural link between listening and
speaking
• Give students
the opportunity to initiate oral communication
• Develop
speaking strategies
Oral communication skills in pedagogical research
1.
Conversational
discourse
• Attention to
conversation rules, sociolinguistic
appropriateness, speech styles, routines,
etc.
2.
Teaching
pronunciation
•
How to teach, yet understanding that accents
will remain
3.
Accuracy
and fluency
• How
to address these two elements of language usage
and language use
4.
Affective
factors
•
Creating a climate that encourages students to speak
and to accept imperfections as part of the
process
5.
Interaction
effect
•
Speaking is a collaborative activity which students must learn to negotiate
6.
Questions
about intelligibility
•
Students must learn to be intelligible, not native speakers
7.
The
growth of spoken corpora
•
The one of the key
development on teaching our production
8.
Genres
of spoken language
•
How to teach variations
of oral intterection
Types of spoken language
•
Monologue
eg lectures,
speeches, recitations.
•
Dialogue eg conversations, interviews, debates, meetings.
Functions of Spoken Language
•
Referential : utterances that provide information.
•
Expressive : utterances
that express the speaker’s feelings.
•
Transactional :
utterances where the main purpose is to get something done or acquire something.
•
Interactional :
utterances where the main emphasis is on the social relationship between the
participants.
•
Phatic : utterances
devoid of any serious content ‘small talk’, usually conducted with
strangers or people only slightly known.
What
makes speaking difficult ?
The main cause of what
makes speaking difficult in the second stage the formulation. The smaller
lexicón or a lack of vocabulary can cause the problem, a weak gramatical and
phonological encoders deteriorate the accuracy and fluency of the speak.
Others cause can be the lack of:
• Clustering:
it’s the fluent speech not word by word, learners can organize their output.
• Redundancy:
it’s making the meaning of the speech clear
• Reduced forms:
it’s necessary to learn the reduced form to sound like a native speaker because
the reduced forms are used in the daily speech.
• Performance variables: it’s the process of thinking as you speak.
• Colloquial language: it’s the acquisition of idioms and phrases of colloquial language.
• Rate of delivery: it’s the acceptable fluency and speeds at the moment of speak.
• Stress, rhythm & intonation: it’s the right intonation and pronunciation of
patterns to send important messages
• Interaction:
it’s the creativity to produce the component waves of language, the creativity
to negotiate the conversation.
Tips
for the teacher:
-
Use the authenthic
language in meaningful context.
-
Give the feedback and
be careful with their corrections
-
Teach in conjunction
with listening
-
Allows
to the student initiate communication
-
Improve the Motivation
using a range of many different techniques.
Tips
for the improve of the fluency and Accuracy
Fluency:
-
speak at normal speed
-
self-correction
-
smooth use of speech
Accuracy: Speaking usig the correct form of
grammar, vocabulary and pronunciation.
Micro- and Macroskills of oral communication
The implications
of those focusing on both the forms of
language and the functions of
language. The Forms of language include the types of
sentences used (declarative, interrogatory, imperative, exclamatory).
Meanwhiie, the functions of language include its purpose and its use.These
include the following:
1. Informative language function: communicating
information, such as facts.
2. Expressive language function: reporting
feelings or attitudes or evoking
these feelings in the reader/listener.
3. Directive language function: using language
to cause or prevent actions, such as in
commands or requests
6 TYPES OF SPEAKING PERFORMANCE (THE KINDS OF ORAL
PRODUCTION THAT THE STUDENTS ARE EXPECTED TO CARRY OUT IN THE CLASSROOM):
1.
IMITATE
A very limited portion of classroom speaking time may
legitimately be spent generating “human tape recorder” speech, where, for
example, learners practice an intonation contour or try to pinpoint a certain
vowel sound. Imitation of this kind is carried out not for the purpose of
meaningful interaction, but for focusing on some particular element of language
form.
New teachers in the field always want the answer to
this question: Is drilling legitimate part of the communicative language
classroom? The answer is a qualifed yes. Drills offer students an opportunity
to listen and to orally repeat certain string of language that may pose some linguistic
difficulty-either phonological or grammatical. Drills are to language teaching
what the pitching machine is the baseball. They offer limited practice through
repetition. They allow one to focus on one element of language in a controlled
activity. They can help to establish certain psychomotor (“to loosen the
tongue”) and to associate selected grammatical forms with their appropriate
context. Here are some useful guidelines for successful drills:
·
Keep them short
(a few minutes of a class hour only)
·
Keep them
simple(preferably just one point at a time)
·
Keep them
“snappy”
·
Make sure
students know why they are doing the drill.
·
Limit them to
phonology or grammar points
·
Make sure they
ultimately lead to communicative goals
·
Do not overuse
them.
2.
INTENSIVE
Intensive speaking goes one step beyond imitative to
include any speaking performance that is designed to practice some phonological
or grammatical aspect of language. Intensive speaking can be self-initiated, or
it can even form part of some pair work activity, where learners are “going
over” certain forms of language.
3.
RESPONSIVE
A good deal of student speech in the classroom is
responsive: short replies to teacher or student initiated questions or
comments. These replies are usually sufficient and do not extend into dialogues
(#4 and #5). Such speech can be meaningful and authentic:
T: how are you today?
S: pretty good, thanks, and you?
4.
TRANSACTIONAL(DIALOGUE)
Transactional language, carried out for the purpose of
conveying or exchanging specific information, is an extended form of responsive
language. Conversations, for example, may have more of a negotiative nature to
them than does responsive speech:
T: What is the main idea in this essay?
S: The United Nations should have more authority
T: More authority than what/
S: Than it does right now
T: What do you mean?
S: Well, for example, the UN should have the power to
force certain countries to destroy its nuclear weapons.
T: You do not think the UN has the power now?
S: Obviously not. Several countries are currently
manufacturing nuclear bombs.
Such conversation could readily be part of group work
activity as well.
5.
INTERPERSONAL(DIALOGUE)
The other form of conversation mentioned in the
previous chapter was interpersonal dialogue, carried out more for the purpose
of maintaining social relationships than for the transmission of facts and
information. These conversation are a little trickier for learners because they
can involve some or all of the following factors:
·
A casual
register
·
Colloquial
language
·
Emotionally
charged language
·
Slang
·
Ellipsis
·
Sarcasm
·
A covert
“agenda”
For example:
Amy: Hi, Bob.
How is it going?
Bob: Oh, so-so
Amy: Not a great
weekend, huh?
Bob: Well, far
be it from me to criticize, but I am pretty miffed about last week
Amy: What are
you talking about?
Bob; I think you
know perfectly well what I am talking about.
Amy: Oh, that ….
How come you get so bent out of shape over something like that?
Bob: Well, whose
fault was it, huh?
Amy: Oh, wow,
this is great. Wonderful. Back to square one. For crying out loud, Bob, I
thought we’d settled this before. Well, what more can I say?
Learners would need
to learn how such features as the relationship between interlocutors, casual
style, and sarcasm are coded linguistically in this conversation.
6.
EXTENSIVE (MONOLOGUE)
Finally, students at intermediate to advanced levels
are called on to give extended monologues in the form of oral reports,
summaries, or perhaps short speeches. Here the register is more formal
deliberative. These monologue can be planned or impromptu.
PRINCIPLES FOR TEACHING SPEAKING SKILLS:
1. Focus on
both fluency and accuracy, depending on your objectives
Accuracy is the extent to which students’ speech matches what peopleactually say when they use the target language. Fluency is the extent towhich speakers use the language quickly and confidently, with few hesitations
or unnatural pauses, false starts, word searches, etc.
In our current interactive language teaching, we can easily slip into
interactive activities that don’t capitalize on grammatical pointers or
pronunciation tips. We need to bear in mind a spectrum of learner needs, from
language-based focus on accuracy to message-based focus on interaction, meaning
and fluency. When you do a jigsaw group technique, play a game, or discuss
solutions to the environmental crisis, make
sure that your tasks have a linguistic (language-based) objective, and seize
the opportunity to help students to perceive and use the building blocks of
language. At the same time, don’t bore your students to death with
lifeless, repetitious drills. As noted above, make any drilling you do as
meaningful as possible. The student can not develop fluency if the teacher is constantly interrupting them to correct their oral errors. Teachers must provide students with fluency
building practice and realize that making mistakes is a natural part of
learning a new language.
2. Provide
intrinsically motivating techniques
Try at all times
to appeal to students’ ultimate goals and
interests, to their need for knowledge, for status, for achieving competence
and autonomy, and for “being all that they can be”. Even in those
techniques that
don’t send
students into ecstasy, help them to see
how the activity will benefit them. Often students don’t know why we ask
them to do certain things, it usually pays to tell them.
3. Encourage
the use of authentic language in meaningful contexts
This theme has
been played time and again. It is not easy to keep coming up with meaningful
interaction. We all succumb to the temptation to do, say, disconnected little
grammar exercises where we go around the room calling on students one by one to
pick the right answer. It takes energy
and creativity to devise authentic contexts and meaningful interaction, but
with the help of a storehouse of teacher resource material, it can be done.
4. Provide
appropriate feedback and correction
In most EFL
situations, students are totally dependent on the teacher for useful linguistic
feedback. In ESL situations, they may get such feedback “out there” beyond the classroom,
but even then you are in a position to be of great benefit. It is important
that you take advantage of your knowledge of English to inject the kinds of
corrective feedback that are appropriate for the moment.
5. Capitalize
on the natural link between speaking and listening
Many interactive
techniques that involve speaking will also of course include listening. Don’t
lose out on opportunities to integrate these two skills. As you are perhaps
focusing on speaking goals, listening goals may naturally coincide, and the two skills can reinforce each other.
Skills in producing language are often initiated through comprehension.
6. Give
students opportunities to initiate oral communication
A good deal of
typical classroom interaction is characterized by teacher initiation of
language. We ask questions, give directions, and provide information and
students have been conditioned only to “speak when spoken to.” Part of oral communication competence is the
ability to initiate conversation, to nominate topics, to ask questions, to
control conversations, and to change the subject. As you design and use
speaking technique, ask yourself if you have allowed students to initiate
language.
7. Encourage the
development of speaking strategies.
The concept of strategic
competence (see Chapter 16:PLLT, chapters 5 and 8) is one that few beginning
language students are aware of. They simply have not thought about developing
their own personal strategies for accomplishing oral communicative purposes.
Your classroom can be done in which students become aware of, and have a chance
to practice, such strategies as:
·
asking for clarification (what?)
·
asking someone to repeat something (pardon me?, Huh?Excuse me?)
·
using fillers (uh, I mean,
Well) in order to gain (to get) time to process
·
using conversation maintenance cues (Uh-huh, Right, Yeah, OK, Hmm)
·
getting someone’s attention (Hey, Say, So)
·
using paraphrasing for structures one can’t produce
·
appealing for assistance from the interlocutor (to get a word or phrase, for
example)
·
using formulaic expressions (at the survival-stage) (How
much does____cost?How do you get to the____?)
·
using mime and non-verbal expressions to convey meaning
TEACHING
CONVERSATION
According to
Richard (1990: 76 – 77) thera are two major approaches characterize current
teaching of conversation :
1.
An Indirect approach in
which learners are more or less set loose to engage in interaction
2.
A direct approach that
involves planning a conversation program around the specific microskills,
strategies, and process that are involved in fluent conversation.
Richard (p. 79) was somewhat critical of
task based instruction, which he labeled an indirect approach, because in the
task the focus is on using language to complete task, rather than on practicing
language.
Richard (1990:78-80) offered the
following list of features of conversation that can receive specific focus in
classroom instruction :
1.
How to use conversation
for both transactional and interactional purposes
2.
How to produce both
short and long turn in conversation
3.
Strategies in managing
turn-taking in conversation, including taking a turn, holding a turn, and
relinguishing a turn.
4.
Strategies for opening
and closing conversation
5.
How to initiate and
respond to talk on a broad range of tropics, and how to develop and maintain
talk on these topics.
6.
How to use both a
casuals type of speaking and a neutral or more formal social gathering
7.
Strategies for
repairing trouble spots in conversation including communication breakdown and
comprehension problems
8.
How to maintain fluency
in conversation through avoiding
excessive pausing, breakdowns, errors of grammar or pronounciation.
9.
How to produce talk in
a conversation mode, using a conversational lister and syntax
10.
How to use
conversational fillers and small talk
11.
How to use conversational
routines.
A.
Conversation-Indirect
(strategy consciounsness-raising)
Plan your time
Level : Intermediate or above
Time : 30-35 minutes
Aim :
for students to consider ways in which they can learn English outside the
classroom.
Preparation: Make fhotocopies of
the task sheet for your class.
Procedure :
1. Arouse student interest in the planning
task.
2.
Set up the initial pair work and give
the students five to ten minutes to discuss, add to, or modify the list of suggestions.
3.
When the initial discussion
is over, you should facilitate the
setting up of the groups. Allow the groups a maximum of twenty minutes
to complete the planning task.
4.
Chair the report-back
session in which each group presents its suggestion. Make posters available to
help the groups present their ideas.
Task
sheet :
Here
is the a of techniques that people use to help them learn English outside the
classroom :
1. Memorizing
a list of words
2. Reading
a grammar book
3. Doing
a grammar exercises
4. Reading
a book or a magazine in Engish
5. Re-copying
things from their class notebook
6. Correcting mistakes made in written work
7. Preparing
the next unit of the coursebook
·
Work with your partner
and add any others of your own. Tell
each other which ones in the list you find helpfull, if any, then tell the
class about the new one you have added.
·
Arrange yourselves in
groups and take a time period from this list :
·
Thirty minutes per day
for six days in a week
·
One hour per day for
five days a week
·
Two hours per day for
four days a week
·
In a group plan a
program to show how you could make use of the time to do extra work on your
English. Use the ideas from the earliest list, as well as any other you can
think of. Choose one person to present your plan to the rest of the class.
Remark
If student
aggree to experiment with a study plan, some time should be allowed in
classroom for them to discuss how they are getting on.
B.
Conversation-Direct
(gambits)
Is
that right ?
Level : Elementary and above
Time : 10 – 15 minutes
Aim : To help
students recognize gambits
Preparation : Find a short cassette
or radio recording of two or three people chatting naturally. Identify examples
of short responses being used and put them in random order on a task sheet,
chalkboard, or OHT, along the following lines. You can add distractors if you
wish. The task sheet might look like this :
Task
sheet : Read the following
list of expression, listen to the tape.
Tick ( ) any of the expression you hear. You may hear some expressions more
than once :
Is
that right : _____________ That’s great !
__________________
Really
...... : _____________ Oh dear __________________
How
interesting : _____________ What a shame
_________________
Er...
hum.... :
_______________ Oh, no __________________
Fine : _______________ You’re joking __________________
I
see : ______________
PROCEDURE
1.
Give a task sheet to
each student and ask them to tick off the examples they hear on the tape.
2.
When they heve done
this, choose two or three examples to focus on and if the students can recall
the utterances that precede or follow them
on the tape.
C.
Conversation
(Transactional (ordering from a catalog)
Informational
Gap Activity
You
are a telephone salesperson for the Best
Wear Company. Your partner is a customer.
Your partner is a costomer. Your partner calls to order some items from
your company’s catalog. Take the order and fill out the order form. Make sure
you have written the order correctly by asking your partner to confirm it.
Don’t look at your partner’s page !
D.
Individual
practice : Oral dialog journals
Written dialogue journals where students
records thoughts, ideas, and/or reactions, and the teacher reads and responds
with written comments.
E.
Other
Interactive techniques
Of course, many
other task and techniques can be applied to the teaching of conversation. They
are almost impossible to categorize, but here are a few possible types, gleaned
simply from the table of contents of
Friederike Klippel’s (1984) practically
litte resource book :
·
Interviews
·
Guessing games
·
Jigsaw tasks
·
Ranking exercises
·
Discussion
·
Values clarification
·
Problem solving
activities
·
Role play
·
Simulations
Pronunciation is an extremely important part of the teaching of English. Regardless of how good a students reading, writing and vocabulary skills are, if they can’t pronounce words correctly, then listeners will not be able to understand them.
Teaching pronunciation can seem quite intimidating to some teachers, particularly if you are a new ESL teacher. However, if you break your task down into step-by-step chunks, it becomes much more simple than it may seem at first.
People from different parts of the world have various difficulties when it comes to pronouncing English words and sounds. For example, there is no ‘R” sound in some languages, and these people tend to use an ‘L’ sound instead.
How To Teach Pronunciation
Start With Sounds
Before you get on with teaching your students how to pronounce words, you should focus on sounds. Begin by teaching your students phonemes. This will pay off in the long run and will prevent your students from making lots of pronunciation mistakes.
Move on to Words
After the students have mastered basic phonemes, including short and long vowels, you can move on to pronunciation of words.
When teaching work pronunciation, teach your students spelling patterns , and associate the phonemes they have already learned with the right spelling patterns. This helps the students to internalize the rules of English spelling and will make it easier for them to pronounce written words correctly.
It’s also helpful to separate words into one-syllable and multi-syllable words. This way they can start with basic words and move onto more complicated ones. Make sure you teach them how to count syllables.
Getting More Advanced: Sentences, Intonation, Rhythm
After getting to grips with phonemes and words, your students can move on to the more difficult part.
Learning sentences and conversation structures can be very complicated for foreign students. There are several factors such as stress, intonation, and rhythm that need to be learned. This part is not easy to teach as it can only really develop naturally over time.
Practice makes perfect, so encourage your students to practice as much as they can at home, and suggest that they watch English TV programs so they can get a feel how people converse in the English language.
One of the main obstacles in teaching pronunciation is the nervousness and lack of confidence that students have. Remember that your role as teacher is to encourage students constantly and praise even their smallest developments. If you can keep your students positive and focused, their development will enhance no doubt.
Practice Stress and Intonation
Students can quickly improve their
English pronunciation skills by focusing on stress and intonation. This lesson
helps students recognize which words to focus on to improve their pronunciation
skills.
Descriptions of the sound and mouth position can help
students increase their awareness of subtle sound differences.
a. a. Voicing
Voiced sounds will make the throat vibrate.
Voiced sounds will make the throat vibrate.
b. b. Aspiration
Aspiration refers to a puff of air when a sound is produced. Many languages have far fewer aspirated sounds than English, and students may have trouble hearing the aspiration. The English /p/, /t/, /k/, and /ch/ are some of the more commonly aspirated sounds.
Aspiration refers to a puff of air when a sound is produced. Many languages have far fewer aspirated sounds than English, and students may have trouble hearing the aspiration. The English /p/, /t/, /k/, and /ch/ are some of the more commonly aspirated sounds.
c.
c. Mouth
Position
Draw simple diagrams of tongue and lip positions. Make sure all students can clearly see your mouth while you model sounds. Have students use a mirror to see their mouth, lips, and tongue while they imitate you.
Draw simple diagrams of tongue and lip positions. Make sure all students can clearly see your mouth while you model sounds. Have students use a mirror to see their mouth, lips, and tongue while they imitate you.
- Intonation
Word or sentence intonation can be mimicked with a kazoo, or alternatively by humming. This will take the students' attention off of the meaning of a word or sentence and help them focus on the intonation. - Linking
We pronounce phrases and even whole sentences as one smooth sound instead of a series of separate words. - Vowel Length
You can demonstrate varying vowel lengths within a word by stretching rubber bands on the longer vowels and letting them contract on shorter ones. Then let the students try it. - Syllable
·
Have
students count syllables in a word and hold up the correct number of fingers,
or
place objects on table to represent each syllable.
·
Illustrate
syllable stress by clapping softly and loudly corresponding to the syllables
of a word.
h.
Specific
Sounds
·
Minimal
pairs, or words such as 'bit/bat' that differ by only one sound, are useful for helping students distinguish
similar sounds.
·
Tongue
twisters are useful for practicing specific target sounds, plus they're fun.
Make sure the vocabulary isn't too difficult.
·
The
Sounds of English, American Accent Training, and
EnglishClub.com websites below offer guidelines for describing how to
produce various English sounds.
The factors within learners that affect pronunciation.
•
Native language
The
native language is the most influential factor affecting a leaner`s
pronunciation.
•
Age
Generally
speaking, children under the age of puberty stand an excellent chance of
“sounding like native” if they have continued exposure in authentic
contexts.
•
Exposure
It
is difficult to define exposure. One can actually live in a foreign country for
some time but not take advantage of being”with the people.
•
Innate phonetic ability
Often referred to as having an “ear” for language, some
people manifest a phonetic coding ability that others do not.
•
Identity and language ego
Yet
another influence is one`s attitude toward speakers of the target language and
the extent to which the language ego identifies with those speakers.
•
Motivation and concern for good pronunciation
Some
learners are not particularly concerned about their pronunciation, while others
are.
How to create a pitch word
Pitch words are created similarly to stressed words. Both kinds of words have some or all of the following characteristics in their stressed syllable:- altered pitch
- lengthening
- increase in loudness
§ However, there are differences between stressed words and pitch words,
both in their creation and their use. In short, the stressed syllables of
pitch words are louder, longer, and have a greater change in pitch than the
stressed syllables of stress words. Pitch words also convey more
information than stressed words.
Differences between stressed words and pitch words
Stressed words are:- the important words of the sentence, the words that comprise the contents of the dialog and help the listener and speaker focus on the same information
- said with a slight pitch change, a little louder, or for more time than surrounding words
- used to create the underlying rhythm of English.
- the most valuable and relevant words, the words that allow the interpretation of the dialog.
- said with a greater change in pitch, loudness, or length of time than stressed words.
Focus
on form and error treatment
• Treatment of Error in Second
Language Student Writing is the book many writing teachers have long been
looking for: a highly accessible and principled approach to the theory and practice of error treatment that
can guide pedagogical decision-making.
Minimal pair
• Minimal pairs are pairs of words
that only have one sound different.
• Example
‘But' and ‘bat' are a minimal pair. Only the vowel sound is different.
‘But' and ‘bat' are a minimal pair. Only the vowel sound is different.
• In the classroom
Minimal pairs are a useful way to highlight a sound in a meaningful context and also to show the learner how important correct pronunciation of the sound is. Activities to practise minimal pairs include reverse dictation (the teacher writes what the learners say on the board), tongue twisters and drilling.
Minimal pairs are a useful way to highlight a sound in a meaningful context and also to show the learner how important correct pronunciation of the sound is. Activities to practise minimal pairs include reverse dictation (the teacher writes what the learners say on the board), tongue twisters and drilling.
Role of Feedback
• Students need to get feedback as
they work. What specific feedback they need depends, of course, on exactly what
they are doing and how they are doing it. Take two students who are learning
biology by playing the part of a manager of a wildlife park. One might need
guidance on how to balance short-term and long-term goals. Another might need
details about what habitat herons prefer.
• Schools tend to not be very good at
giving students the feedback they need. Sometimes, the only feedback a student
gets is a grade. When students do get feedback that has some content to it,
it's typically because they get it during class discussion when all the
students are getting the same feedback at the same time.
When and How to treat Errors
When we should
threat the error is not easy. James
hendrickson advised teachers to try to discern the difference between global
and local errors. Hendrickson recommended that local errors usually need not be
corrected since the message is clear and correction might interrupt a
learner in the flow of productive
communication. Global errors need to be threated in some way since the massage
may otherwies remain garbled. Many utterances are not clearly global or local,
and it is difficult to discern nessecity for corrective feedback.
The matter of
how to treat eerors is complex. Research
on error correction methode is not at all conclusive on the most effective
method or technique. It seems quite clear that students in the classroom
generally want and expect errors to be be corrected. However some method
reccomend no direct treatment of
error at
all. The research William shows the best way to help a learner to repair
malformed utterances is, first, to assist the learner in noticing an incorrect
form ( trough recast, prompts, and other attention-getting divices ) and
second, for the learner to initiate repair ( with as little promting as
possible from the teacher ). The teacher needs to develop the intuition, trough
experience and established theoretical fondation, for ascertaining which option
or combination of options is appropriate at given moments. Principles of
optimal affective and cognitive feedback, of reinforcement theory, and of
communicative language teaching all combine to form those intuitions. There are
some information “ A model for treatment of classroom speech errors “.
DEVIANT
UTTERANCE
1. Type
( lexical, phonological, grammatical,discourse,pragmatic,sociocultural)
2. Source
(L1,L2, teacher induced other ss, outside L2 input,print, electronic media)
3. Linguistic
Complexity (intricate and involved, easy to explain/deal with
4. Local
or Global
5. Mistake
or Error
6. Learner’s
Affective state (Language ego fragility, anexiety, confidence, receptiveness)
7. Learner’s Linguistic State ( emergent, presystematic, systematic,
postsystematic.
8. Pedagogical
Focus ( immediate task goals,lesson objectives, course goals/purposes
9. Communicative
context ( conversation flow factors, individual,group, or whole class work.
10. Teacher
Style ( direct or indirect, interventionist, laizzes-faire )
Based on the information above, now we
ready to decide wether to treat or ignore the deviation, if you decide to do
nothing you simply move on. But if you decide to do something in the way of
treatment, you have a number of treatment options, you have to decide when to
treat, who will treat, and how to treat. Notice that you,the teacher do not
always have to be the person who provides the treatment. Manner of treatment
varies according to the input to the students, the directness of the treatment,
the students output and the teacher follow up.
ASSESING SPEAKING IN THE CLASSROOM
Assesing speaking skills in the
classroom has one clear adventages over assesing listening: speech is
observable, recordable, and measureable. However, once the criterion of your
assesment moves beyond the phonological level, this advantage quickly dissapear
as acceptable responses are more difficult to specify reliably. There are three
criteria in speaking assessing in the classroom :
1. Specify
the category of speaking performance ( from imitative to extensive)
2. Describe
micro and macro skills that are to be assessed
3. The
genre of spoken language that being assessed
Item Types and Task for Assessing
speaking
There are some options for assessing
spoken languange at the various levels of performance :
1. Imitative
speaking tasks
Ø minimal
pair repetition
Ø word/phrase
repetition
Ø sentence
repetition
2. Intensive
speaking tasks
Ø directed
response
Ø read-aloud
Ø oral
sentence completion
Ø oral
cloze procedure
Ø dialogue
completion
Ø Picture
cued elicitation of grammatical item
Ø Translation
3. Responsive
speaking tasks
Ø picture
cued elicitation of response or description
Ø map
cued elicitation of directions
Ø question
and answer
Ø question
elicitation
Ø elicitation
of instructions
Ø paraphrasing
4. Interactive
speaking tasks
Ø oral
interviews
Ø role
plays
Ø discussions
and conversations
Ø games
5. Extensive
speaking task
Ø Oral
presentations ( in academic or profesional contexts )
Ø Picture
cued ( extensive ) story telling
Ø Retelling
a story or news event
Ø Translation
of an extended text
Evaluating and Scoring Speaking Tasks
The
evaluation of oral pruduction performance can quite complicated. The first we have to be clear about the level
language that our targeting. There are at least six possible criteria that we
can use :
1. Pronunciation
2. Fluency
3. Vocabulary
4. Grammar
5. Discourse
features ( cohesion, sosiolinguistic appropriateness)
6. Task
(accomplishing the objective of the task )
Some scales add “ comprehension “ to
account for the extent to which a student has comprehended directions or
elicitation. We can use categories such as, beginning, intermediate, and
advanced as potential levels. Whatever
category that you use the most important is to describe them as clearly as
possible in order to make reliable evaluations.
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar